Lung function and vaping: a statistically non-significant pilot study drew criticism from experts

A pilot study of 22 people published in the journal Tobacco Control suggested a decline in expiratory volume, but the result was not statistically significant. Independent researchers have warned of serious methodological shortcomings, including the lack of a control group.

The pilot study published in the journal Tobacco Control examined the lung function of 22 adults over approximately one year who had used e-cigarettes in the previous 30 days. The researchers observed that forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV₁) decreased with more frequent use, but this trend was not statistically significant. Although the authors raised the possibility of a risk of declining lung function, they also acknowledged that their data were preliminary.

Researchers consulted by the Science Media Centre highlighted several methodological shortcomings. Professor Katie East pointed to the lack of a control group, the extremely small sample size, and the fact that participants could have smoked up to five conventional cigarettes in the preceding month, which could act as a confounding factor. Professor Lion Shahab identified six specific flaws, emphasizing that after applying the statistical correction required for multiple testing, none of the FEV₁ values remained statistically significant.

According to Professor Shahab, the study’s reported annual FEV₁ decline of around 100 milliliters is difficult to interpret biologically, as it is far more dramatic than even the 40-milliliter annual decline typically seen in smokers. Experts stressed that reliable conclusions can only be drawn from larger, longer-term studies that include a control group.

In brief

  • A one-year pilot study of 22 adults observed declining lung function FEV₁ among e-cigarette users.
  • The observed association was not statistically significant, and all effects disappeared after statistical corrections.
  • According to Science Media Centre experts, the lack of a control group, the small sample, and concurrent smoking mean the study does not provide sufficient evidence.
  • The authors and independent experts agree that much larger, controlled studies are needed for a reliable assessment.

Source: Vapoteurs (vapoteurs.net)

This summary was generated by artificial intelligence based on the original article.