A British study suggests that vaping impairs vascular function to a similar extent as smoking, but independent experts have strongly criticized the sweeping conclusions drawn from a sample of just 17 people.
In the study published in the journal JAMA Cardiology, researchers from Manchester Metropolitan University assessed the vascular function of 58 adults (aged 18–45). Participants were divided into three groups: 17 vapers (who had smoked fewer than 100 cigarettes in their lifetime), 19 smokers who smoked at least five cigarettes a day, and 22 non-users. Participants underwent laboratory tests twice within a single week, measuring flow-mediated dilation (FMD), carotid artery reactivity, exercise capacity on a stationary bike, and lung function.
The results showed that both vapers and smokers had poorer vascular measures than non-users, although there was no significant difference between the two groups. During exercise, ventilation and cardiac output remained lower in both user groups; maximum oxygen consumption was significantly lower in vapers than in non-users, while smokers showed no statistically meaningful difference. The researchers found no substantial differences between the groups in lung function or activity levels.
Experts consulted by the Science Media Centre highlighted serious limitations: a sample of just 17 vapers does not provide sufficient statistical power to compare the groups. Moreover, the cross-sectional study provides only a snapshot, so participants’ baseline vascular health is unknown, and the limit of fewer than 100 cigarettes smoked means that the effects of past smoking cannot be completely ruled out.
In brief
- The study compared the vascular and physical health of 17 vapers, 19 smokers, and 22 non-users over the course of a week.
- Vapers and smokers had poorer vascular function and exercise capacity measures than non-users.
- The authors acknowledge that cross-sectional data cannot establish a direct cause-and-effect relationship.
- According to British researchers, the authors substantially overinterpreted the results given the sample size of 17 and the methodological shortcomings.
Source: VapingPost FR (fr.vapingpost.com)
This summary was produced by artificial intelligence based on the original article.