Fact check: vaping is not "a hundred times worse" than conventional cigarettes

Scientific evidence and large-scale studies refute the claim made on Twitch that e-cigarettes are one hundred times more harmful than smoking.

A Quebec-based content creator claimed in a Twitch stream that vaping is “a hundred times worse” than traditional cigarettes and delivers significantly more nicotine into the body. However, based on professional studies and toxicological measurements, this statement is completely unfounded, and there is no trace of such data in the scientific literature.

American and British studies – including a survey of over 5,000 people in the United States – confirm that the concentration of toxic substances in the bodies of exclusive e-cigarette users is 10–98 percent lower compared to smokers. According to summaries by the British Royal College of Physicians and the U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM), switching completely significantly reduces exposure to carcinogenic components, although dual use eliminates this benefit.

The study of nicotine intake also debunked the claims made in the broadcast: according to a London-based study, traditional cigarettes resulted in a blood nicotine level of 17.9 ng/ml, while the studied e-cigarettes reached only 7.5–9.7 ng/ml. While vaping is not completely risk-free for non-smokers, there is no indication that it is more dangerous than combustible tobacco.

In Brief

  • The claim that vaping is 100 times more harmful than traditional cigarettes is scientifically unfounded.
  • Exclusive e-cigarette users have 10–98% fewer toxic substances in their blood and urine compared to smokers.
  • Measurements show that blood plasma nicotine levels reached 17.9 ng/ml when smoking, while it remained at 7.5–9.7 ng/ml when vaping.
  • The relative health benefits are only realized with a complete switch; dual use negates them.

Source: VapingPost FR (fr.vapingpost.com)

This summary was created by artificial intelligence based on the original article.

3 Likes