The European Commission’s Regulatory Scrutiny Board has rejected the impact assessment prepared for the revision of the Tobacco Products Directive, which may delay the submission of the proposal.
The European Commission’s Regulatory Scrutiny Board (RSB) has issued a negative opinion on the impact assessment accompanying the revision of the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) and the Tobacco Advertising Directive. Due to the decision of the independent quality control body, the presentation of the EU legislative proposal, the TPD3, originally expected by the end of 2026, is expected to be pushed back to 2027.
The board does not examine political goals but rather checks the quality and evidence-base of the preparatory materials. According to reports, the RSB objected to the proportionality of the planned measures, the incomplete tax and socio-economic analyses, and the legal basis for EU-level bans in areas that largely fall under member state competence.
Critique was particularly emphasized regarding the insufficiency of evidence brought forward for the alleged “gateway effect” between vaping and smoking. Following the negative opinion, DG Santé is required to revise the impact assessment and resubmit it to the board before the College of Commissioners can adopt the official proposal.
In short
- The RSB issued a negative opinion on the European Commission’s impact assessment prepared for the TPD revision.
- Due to the decision, the presentation of the TPD3 proposal could slip from the end of 2026 to 2027.
- According to the critique, the evidence supporting the vaping gateway effect is insufficient, and the legal basis for EU-level bans is doubtful.
- DG Santé must revise the document before it can be submitted to the commissioners.
Source: VapingPost FR (fr.vapingpost.com)
This summary was generated by artificial intelligence based on the original article.