A new study finds that national regulations differ significantly in how they interpret smoking-cessation evidence, ranging from support in New Zealand to a total ban in India. The researchers propose a model that protects young people while providing regulated harm-reduction pathways for adults.
The researchers examined national policy documents, clinical guidelines, and evidence-certainty assessments across eight jurisdictions, analyzing how smoking-cessation evidence is applied in practice. Although the 2025 Cochrane review found high-certainty evidence that nicotine e-cigarettes are more effective than traditional nicotine replacement therapies for smoking cessation, national responses range from government programs in New Zealand to a criminal ban in India.
The study contrasts the United Kingdom’s harm-reduction model with South Korea’s abstinence-focused approach. Citing the protection of young people, South Korean authorities have introduced restrictions that deny adult smokers access to harm reduction, while also continuing to uphold an earlier EVALI warning—even though their own product testing found no THC and only negligible traces of vitamin E acetate.
The authors found that applying the same GRADE assessment framework to different clinical questions can produce opposing conclusions because of local traditions and institutional attitudes. They therefore propose a dual-track model that combines strict protection for young people with regulated harm reduction for adults.
In brief
- The Cochrane review finds that nicotine e-cigarettes are demonstrably more effective than traditional nicotine replacement therapies.
- Policy responses vary dramatically around the world: New Zealand supports e-cigarettes, while India bans them.
- South Korea continues to uphold its EVALI warning despite its own tests finding no THC in the products.
- The researchers recommend dual regulation that provides both protection for minors and harm reduction for adults.
Source: PubMed (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
This summary was generated by artificial intelligence based on the original article.